"All About Eve" is a movie that is clearly not in my wheelhouse. The fact that I found myself watching it on Saturday and Sunday is a mystery within itself.Well, that may be a lie. I am currently reading a book entitled "Vanity Fair's Tales of Hollywood: Rebels, Reds, and Graduates and the Wild Stories Behind the Making of 13 Iconic Films," of which "Eve" is one of.
Anyway, I was originally going to watch all 13 movies after I read each essay, but that won't happen because I'm not sophisticated enough to appreciate "Eve" because movies were a different beast back then. "Eve" had to feel like a Quentin Tarantino picture based on 1950s standards because the film is 99 percent dialogue-driven - snappy comebacks, well-placed lines, and supporting actors nailing their roles, no matter how big or small.
The movie stars Bette Davis as Margo and Anna Baxter as her femme fatale, Eve Harrington. Both shine in their roles (both received Best Actress nominations) and Eve does a masterful job buttering up Margo and then pulling the rug out from under her.
Although many consider this movie Davis' best film, there is A LOT of overacting on her part, whether its the lengthy sequence where we first meet Eve and her fake back-story and the dinner scene where Eve blackmails Margo's best friend, Kim Richards, played by Celeste Holm. Regardless, Davis more or less nails the part of entitled superstar coming to grips with her age.
This movie does nothing to get rid of the theory that all girls/women hate each other - even their friends. How in the world can Kim Richards betray Margo by siphoning the gas in her OWN car so that they can't make the train which lets Eve, who has magically become Margo's understudy, star that particular night?
And then, even though she gives Eve her big break, Kim does a 180 and decides to despise Eve for what she's done to Margo. WTF, ladies? My only complaint with Baxter's performance is that her voice is so over-the-top innocent at the beginning and she's way too nice. No one is unrealistically as "nice and helpful" as she was to Margo. That should've been a dead giveway of Eve Harrington's cruel intentions - something which Birdie was onto from the get-go, although she showed jealous tendencies as well.
Ladies, ladies, ladies - can't we all just get along? Why the backstabbing? Why the hatred? Why do you have to use Margo to get to the top, Eve? Why put the knife in your best friend, Kim? Why do you choose such terrible friends and hangers-on, Margo? Someone needs to go to the Vincent Chase school for Entourage Selection.
Let's touch on Eve for a second. Although I chided her over-the-top voice in the beginning, she does that to set up the climax, which was wonderfully shot. Baxter does a great job of voice inflection (COMM 210 buzzword! - I used to teach this class at Ball State, after all) throughout, using her vindictive voice to blackmail Kim, and then when her own obsessed fan shows up at the end, all of the sudden Eve has a raspy voice and some attitude issues, not unlike Margo.
Great supporting performances as well from George Sanders as gossip mongor - and eventually Eve paramour - Addison Stevens and Gary Merrill as Margo's boyfriend/fiance/husband Bill Simpson. And Marilyn Monroe is in the movie for a whole two minutes and I must say, she looks really, really hot in this movie.
Through the first 2/3 of this movie, I was not a fan as I wondered how this was considered a masterpiece. I'm trying not to hate on old movies - loved "Citizen Kane" and "Casablanca" and enjoyed "From Here to Eternity" while some others were a bit iffy. What "Eve" does is give us numerous opportunities to use it in pop culture moments. It's the Wally Pipp of the entertainment world. Whenever someone flips the switch like Eve did to Margo, an All About Eve reference is sure to follow.
By the end of the movie, I eventually warmed up to it. But it is very, very slow and you have to get through a lot of meandering since it's set up like a play. But once you get to the heart of the movie, you have a very interesting story of betrayal and hated amongst girlfriends. I wonder if every girl hates the other because of what happens in "Eve."
That's what I got out of it, anyway.





